Library clips

sharing ideas thoughts and feedback

October 2, 2008

Google Blog Search Memetracker

Google Blog Search (GBS) is now memetracking, similar to services such as Megite and Techmeme.

You can filter by a number of categories such as Science, Technology, Entertainment, Business, Politics, etc..

The look and feel is no way close to Techmeme.

Clustering

GBS clusters stories similar to Google News.

Techmeme does something similar but, it does this 2 ways:

1. Stories that link to the main story are clustered as Discussion items (where you can expand to see, rather than GBS launching a new page which loses the context of where you are)

2. Stories that don’t link to the main story but are equally popular are clustered as Related Items (these Related Items also have their own Discussion Items)

In Context and Snapshots

Another thing I like is that when you search Techmeme, you can view an item “In context” which launches to the unique URL of the story with all its clustered items

- whereas when you search GBS, it’s just a standard results page, there’s no way to view that item in context

One thing though, on Techmeme how do I get a unique URL for an item without having to search for it, and click “In context”, how come these unique links aren’t hyperlinks under an item on the homepage?

What I like about Techmeme is that you can enter a date and time and view a snapshot of what was happening that day/time.

The Juice

Techmeme is just more usable and looks supreme, but the difference here is that Techmeme only tracks a set of blogs, whereas GBS tracks the whole blogosphere.

- I’m not sure on the differences in how these services rank popularity, authoritativeness, and influence.

- as Marshall Kirkpatrick says, another feature for breaking news bloggers is who’s actually faster at collating the news everyone wants to know

More

Now let’s see this as my Google Reader homepage.

As an alternative to Google Reader, how about a customised Google Blog Search page, just like Google News Customised.

What I’ve always liked about Megite is that you can make your own memetracker via your OPML, I guess this would be similar as a Google Reader homepage memetracker…Megite also throws in recommended items into the mix.

So what about a social OPML memetracker, that is, base the blogosphere on my OPML and my Google Reader friends OPML (just pretending that Google Reader is a social network).

What I’ve always wanted is a widget for an item on Techmeme…meme clip blogging.

eg. imagine if this screenshot was a live widget

Related

Moopz - Friendfeed memetrackerFriendFeed are now clustering duplicate items (not quite memetracking, but lessens the noise)

Tweetmeme - Twitter memetracker

UPDATE: I just noticed Twitter are doing Newmastering pages just like Google Reader

July 14, 2008

Moopz the self organising memetracker, and other Friendfeed friends

Moopz comes to the rescue for a concern I too have had about Friendfeed, and that is, fragmented conversations within Friendfeed itself.
The issue is that there may be conversations around multiples of the same item:

- just say my blog feed posts my latest item to Friendfeed (it’s a post about something I have on Slideshare)
- my latest Slideshare activity will post an item to Friendfeed as well
- and someone bookmarks that blog post or slidedeck URL on del.icio.us which then shows up on Friendfeed
- someone tweets about it, and that shows up on Friendfeed
- someone may even post directly into Friendfeed about the slidedeck

As you can see above there are 5 opportunities to initiate the same conversation about the same thing within Friendfeed, and the most thriving conversation may be around someone’s bookmarked item of your post, rather than around the feed item of your own post.

As Read Write Web point out, at the moment your re-syndicated blog post may not have any discussion in Friendfeed, but an A-lister who bookmarks your blog post will have lots of discussion around that item in Friendfeed.
This is a new dynamic as now people are becoming a hot spot, a community onto themselves, for not only their own content, but content of others.

Moopz plans to prevent this fragmentation from happening.

For starters it only displays content that has links, so you won’t see tweets saying “Good morning Twitter!”

If a new link that appears is already linked to in another Friendfeed item, then they will be merged (clustered together) preventing fragmented conversation from even happening.

Another good thing about this is that we don’t have to see duplicate items.

And each item is auto-tagged meaning you can browse conversations on a topic

I guess this is a memetracker of sorts based on clusterings, and what gets on the frontpage is decided as a result of people using the system. This makes it a more self organising version of Techmeme and Megite…and a more limited version as it’s only based on content that comes from the aggregate of user profiles.

Megite allows you to enter your OPML, and displays most popular and recommended posts from people you care about (rather than all items ranked), but it’s not a conversation platform. It also displays memes by topic.

At the moment Moopz only has a public timeline, hopefully soon it can be personalised to have a friends timeline.

Like Megite and Techmeme, Moopz will display popular memes based on links, but it doesn’t scour the web for these links and cluster them, instead it scours content people have re-syndicate into it’s own system…the former Memetrackers also use other methods like concept analysis (as two items may be about the same exact thing yet they both don’t point to a common link).
Moopz also has another aspect to popular memes, and that’s based on the amount of conversation that happens within Moopz (Friendfeed) itself.

More

Also checkout how Read Write Web and Louis Gray are incorporating Friendfeed comments back to their blog (the original source)…Read Write Web also allow posting to Friendfeed from within their blog.

Louis Gray has some great Friendfeed tips every Friday, the first one on the hide funtion is a great way to reduce the noise, and same with advanced search.

NoiseRiver (via LG)

Another way to filter the flow by a feature called “My Interests”, enabling you to use a drop down menu to filter in or out items containing a certain keyword, the filter choices are:
I love it so much!, I love it, I like it, This is nice, It’s OK, I don’t care, It stinks, This is bad, I don’t like it, I hate it, I hate it so much
There’s also a feature called “My Neighbourhood” to filter items from people on a similar filtering menu.
I also noticed:
- you can re-share an item (this posts it as a FF post)
- there is a reply icon next to each item and comment so your comment is pre-pended with that person name eg. @louis
- each item has auto-keywords (not sure why you can add/delete them, you can also filter rate these keywords as explained above)
- “hide all entries with this URL” is a manual way of doing what Moopz already does.

FeedMachine (via LG)

This brings an element of an RSS reader because you can mark read/unread

Friends view - contact list where you can choose a contact and click on a source icon and a box displays latest content from that source…it lacks latest content from all a person’s sources

Good Friends View - When you click on a profile it allows you to tick that person as a good friend, this will add them to your Good Friends section

Stream View - latest items from all friends
When you click on the info icon it loads the original item on the right and the FF comments on the left, where you can post a comment
- sort by: newsest, oldest, unread, user, service, item text, comments, most liked, least liked
- hide duplicates

Just like NoiseRiver and Moopz you filter out entries by keyword, as well as user, service, hide read items, and hide “@” items

Mio News (via LG)

This turns Friendfeed into an RSS Reader, kind of reminds me of Spokeo.

On your subscription pane you have an icon to see your FF stream (mark as read).
You also have an icon for each friend, clicking this will stream the latest from a friend (mark as read).
You can group friends into folders, click on a folder will show you the latest from just those friends in that folder (mark as read).

But, you can’t filter your whole stream, a folder stream, or one friend by service.

This has an MS Outlook feel, as when you click on an item you see the full-text on the 3rd pane, from here you can:
- mark as read, share on FF (also share to your blog, twitter, and email), comment, like, hate, goto native item

There also a bookmarklet and blog and Twitter integration.

Lastly there is a “Topics” feature where you list keywords (also organise in folders)
- clicking on a keyword will display all items from your friends about that keyword (not sure if it’s “about” or just the appearance of the keyword)

At the moment you can’t view rooms, or share an item to a room.

This could be a replacement for Google Reader, it would be good if you could manually adds feeds from non-FF people so I don’t need two RSS Readers.

Related:
FriendFeed Rooms : Interactive topic streams
Friendfeed : social filter conversations

April 15, 2008

Roundup : SlideRocket, RSSmeme, Shyftr, Fraxi, Flux

OFFICE
SlideRocket - yet another online presentation service, see more here.
[via RWW]

RSS - MEME
RSSmeme - similar to ReaderBurner (now about to be resurrected), RSSmeme tracks shared items from various Google Reader users creating a hot news site.
[via mashable]

RSS - READER - NETWORK
Shyftr - a new social network RSS Reader like FeedEachOther mentioned above, and something Google Reader will eventually do…the ability to add friends, visit users, message friends, comment on items, send friends links, share links which can be aggregated into a hot meme pages like RSSmeme mentioned above.
A lot of use won’t move from Google Reader no matter how much more hip these new social readers are, so something like FriendFeed (FF) becoming a social network might gain more traction with my existing network…FF is not an RSS Reader, but in a similar realm.
[via RWW]

MEME-BOOKMARKS
Fraxi - now the makers Pligg who offer a non-hosted way for you to create your own social bookmarks/memedigger are also offering a hosted version called Fraxi, also see CoRank.
[via TC]

NETWORK
Flux - create your own social network, also see Ning.
[via TC]

Get free blog up and running in minutes with Blogsome | Theme designs available here